• 5331 Keystone Drive, Fort Wayne, IN 46825
  • |Contact Us
24/7 Emergency Service Available

Steel vs. Aluminum Garage Doors: Which Is Better?

So, you’re ready for a new garage door, and you know you want one made out of metal — but did you know you have the choice between steel and aluminum? If you’re wondering which one is better, we’ll go ahead and tell you that there’s no “right” answer to that question. It totally depends on your home’s style, needs and budget.

With this blog, we hope to give you some guidelines for choosing between steel and aluminum for your new garage door, but contact us if you have any questions!

Benefits of Steel Garage Doors

Steel is the most popular material for garage doors, and with good reason — steel garage doors likely offer the best bang for your buck in most situations. This material is extremely durable and likely to last about as long as your home. Because of their popularity, it’s pretty easy to find the right-sized steel garage door for your home. Furthermore, steel doors are customizable, so you can get the style you want and add some curb appeal to your home’s facade.

Steel garage doors are:

Durable. Steel garage doors are built to endure the elements, including driving rain, heavy winds and intense summer heat and humidity.

Low-maintenance. Prepainted steel doors require little more than an annual spray with the hose to keep them looking like new, and your steel garage door can be repainted if desired.

Versatile. Steel is exceptionally strong, but it is also malleable enough to accept all types of finishes, resulting in unlimited design and color options. This versatile material can be used to construct any garage door, including:

  • Sectional garage doors
  • Side-hinged garage doors
  • Traditional up-and-over garage doors
  • Rolled garage doors

Strong. A high-quality steel garage door offers exceptional protection and security against break-ins, physical damage and everyday wear and tear.

Environmentally friendly. Your new steel garage door may be constructed from recycled materials and recycled again at the end of its life.

Benefits of Aluminum Garage Doors


Aluminum garage doors share many characteristics with steel garage doors, but aluminum is lighter than steel. Aluminum doors tend to be less expensive than steel, so they can be a good option for families looking to save money on their garage door replacement.

Aluminum garage doors are:

Lightweight. An aluminum garage door is easy to install, and the lighter weight places less stress on torsion springs and tracks for increased longevity and fewer repairs.

Corrosion-resistant. Since aluminum is naturally resistant to rust and corrosion, it is ideal in most climates and coastal areas where the salty ocean air and moisture may damage other materials.

Recyclable. Aluminum garage doors may be made from recycled materials and recycled again at the end of their life.

Low-maintenance. This water-resistant material won’t rust and requires little more than a periodic spray with the hose to look its best.

Questions to Ask When Deciding Between Steel & Aluminum Garage Doors

When you’re deciding between these two types of materials for your garage door, there are several things you’ll have to consider. Questions you should ask yourself include:

  • What is my budget? While prices vary depending on each garage door’s specific model and unique feature, steel tends to be more expensive than aluminum. However, higher-quality aluminum doors can rival steel in price, and steel is a bit more durable, so it may have better value over time.
  • Do I care about rust resistance? Aluminum is a much more rust-resistant material than steel, but steel doors can be coated with a protective coating to help prevent rust. If you opt for a steel door and want to help ensure rust isn’t an issue, make sure it’s coated!
  • How durable do I want my garage door to be? While aluminum doors are partially dent-resistant, steel is much stronger. If you’re worried that storms might throw tree branches or other debris toward your home, a steel door might be the better option.

Quality Steel & Aluminum Garage Doors in Fort Wayne, IN

No matter which material you choose, Overhead Door Company of Fort Wayne can help you with your garage door replacement project. If you’re not sure whether a steel or aluminum garage door is the best fit for your home, we’ll discuss your needs and budget to help you decide.

To schedule your garage door installation appointment, give us a call today at 260-205-8509 or contact us online.

Are You Sure?
Stay on Page
You are about to leave this IBP Ft. Wayne and enter a third-party site. IBP Ft. Wayne and Installed Building Products have no control over, and accept no liability, obligation, or responsibility for, the contents or performance of other websites. Any such link does not constitute an endorsement or any representation regarding, the linked website, its content, its owner, its performance, its owner’s products or services, or any forward-looking statements found in.
Leave Page
Stay on Page